Saturday, April 15, 2017

Road Food - Foodie Nonfiction Review

I love food and I love travel and when I came across Road Food: An Eater's Guide to More Than 1,000 of the Best Local Hot Spots and Hidden Gems Across America by Jane and Michael Stern I just couldn't resist.  This fairly hefty guide book that focuses on restaurants is divided by region and then by state.  Each state includes about a dozen or so restaurant recommendations from all over the state.

I love road trips and heading off the beaten path and I was super excited to page through this book looking for culinary ideas across the country.  This edition was published in 2017 so the information is as up to date as it can be.

Now while I love the idea of long road trips with kids in college my travel budget has taken a bit of a hit so for now most of my travel is vicarious so I can't really put this to use right this moment.  I can, however, check it out from the prospective of a local for the places that I'm familiar with.

First up is my home state - Alabama.  There are 11 restaurants listed and 4 of those are in Mobile but only 2 are in Birmingham which is quickly earning it's place on foodie lists as a place to go.  Neither of the 2 listed from Birmingham are familiar to me though I have heard of the barbecue place that's mentioned in nearby Bessemer.  A little farther north in Madison Greenbrier Restaurant is mentioned.  Now I've eaten at Greenbrier several times and while I agree that the hush puppies are amazing I question why Greenbrier is listed and not the far more highly regarded Big Bob Gibson's which created the white barbecue sauce that North Alabama is so famous for.  In both cities I felt like there were several omissions that I questioned especially Post Office Pies in Birmingham (a really fun place with wood fire grilled pizza in a restored old post office) and Cyn Shea's, Blue Plate Cafe, and Pane E Vino (which also happens to be under the art museum) in Huntsville.  As well it left out Auburn and Opelika which both have some amazing and unique restaurants.

So then I hopped the state line into Mississippi.  Once again I found some odd omissions.  In McComb (a tiny railroad town in the southwest part of the state) The Dinner Bell is the only restaurant listed.  The Dinner Bell is an okay meat and three which does have a fun lazy Susan style setup to pass dishes in a family style table but is hardly a memorable meal.  However, it ignores the amazing sandwich place down the street called Topisaw General Store which has fresh offerings every day - everything delicious and made from scratch with just a touch of something to make the offerings unique.  I have dreams of their corn salad and carrot cake and their pizzas are beyond delicious.  And we're not even going to talk about their quiche because I will want one and there's no where else I can get a Ham and Pimento Cheese quiche that tastes like theirs and there aren't many problems their sweet tea slushie can't fix. A little farther east in Hattiesburg Leatha's Bar-B-Que Inn which is a bit of a dive but has good barbecue is listed but there's no mention of Crescent City Grill.  It's a little more upscale but still family friendly with a draft list as long as my arm, amazing burgers topped with crab cakes and a bread pudding that haunts my dreams.

I had similar experiences in the chapters about Georgia, Florida, Tennessee, and North Carolina.  Everything mentioned was good but there were a number of omissions that I thought were better.  I don't think this book would lead you astray but at the same time I don't think it's all that more useful than Yelp.  Since I received a copy of this book through Blogging for Books in exchange for an honest review I'll keep it on hand and do some reading when I have my next actual trip to a place I'm unfamiliar with but I don't think I'll be recommending that anyone go rush out and buy this one.

I'm linking up with Weekend Cooking hosted by Beth Fish Reads

12 comments:

  1. I own an older version of this book and I found it to be an ok read. I don't live in the states so I bought it as just another travel guide book and I also hoped it would be full of pictures which it wasn't.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I was I was curious about this book but have passed over it a few times. Your review has me sold, I am going to get this from Blogging for Books next time, if it's still available. We love finding off the beaten track places.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I too remember an older version and had the same experience as you. Now with the Internet and smartphones, I wonder if we need such books at all.

    ReplyDelete
  4. You are lucky if there are some new discoveries in this book for you! I've been following Jane and Michael Stern for a long time, and follow the Road Food page on Facebook too. Once I even heard them in a panel discussion at a book festival!

    best... mae at maefood.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  5. Don't think I'd get this one, as I'd always be wondering about the omissions and whether the places mentioned were all that great. Good honest review.

    ReplyDelete
  6. With everything out there, this book got such Press when it first came out years back, I wasn't at all interested. It is not an overall or all inclusive look, but their personal experiences. The only thing close to that kind of reviews is a Zagat guide

    ReplyDelete
  7. The Topisaw General Store sounds like my kinda place! And mmm hush puppies. :)

    ReplyDelete
  8. Sounds like this book would be interesting to look at anyway, if nothing else for cross reference. Thanks for featuring it.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I think you should write a book about road trip foods!

    ReplyDelete
  10. I would love to find all of the off the beaten path restaurants. Too bad this one left off some notable ones. I used to take my family out to new places as much as I could but now with food allergies we stick with what we know to be safe. Boring but safe.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I need to know what they say for South Dakota.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I am always intrigued by what places and foods show up in books like this--and which ones don't. It looks like a fun read. ;-)

    ReplyDelete